Book

Wintering

Katherine May

Katherine May's case that the fallow, difficult stretches of life, a loss, a burnout, an illness, a plain bad year, aren't failures to snap out of, but seasons with their own logic. An uncommon lens for leaders who treat every low point as a problem to solve away fast.

Wintering Find this on the mind-map

Introduction

Katherine May's book is built around a reframing: a "winter," in her usage, is any difficult, fallow, low-energy period in life, grief, illness, burnout, a career setback, a plain stretch of feeling stuck, and the common instinct to treat it as an emergency to be fixed and exited as fast as possible is, in her argument, exactly backwards. Winter, in nature, isn't a malfunction of the year. It's a necessary season with its own function. May's claim is that personal winters work the same way, and fighting them, rather than moving through them deliberately, usually makes them longer and harder, not shorter.

Winter Is a Season, Not a Failure

The book's central move is separating the fact of being in a hard period from the judgment that being in one means something has gone wrong with you. May points out that winters come to almost everyone, repeatedly, across a working life. The person who seems to have simply avoided them has usually just hidden theirs well. A manager going through a genuinely difficult personal stretch while trying to project constant competence is spending real energy on the performance of being fine, energy that isn't available for actually getting through the thing.

Doing Winter Well, Not Fighting It

May draws on how some cultures and communities face literal harsh winters well, not by denying the season or rushing through it, but by adapting their pace, their expectations, and their social rhythms to match it, and treats this as a template for a personal winter too. Doing winter well means lowering your own expectations of your output during it, deliberately, rather than holding yourself to a summer-level pace while falling apart trying to meet it without telling anyone. Picture two directors going through a hard divorce at the same time. One insists on running every meeting exactly as before, refuses any accommodation, and burns out within two months, visibly and publicly. The other tells their own manager honestly that this is a hard season, deliberately narrows their scope for a stretch, and comes out the other side with the relationships and the role still intact.

Retreat Is Not the Same as Giving Up

A recurring theme pushes back on the instinct to treat withdrawal, rest, or a narrowed focus during a hard period as weakness or defeat. May treats retreat as an active, necessary strategy: animals that hibernate aren't failing to survive winter, they're surviving it precisely by retreating, and argues the same logic applies to a person pulling back from social obligations, ambitions, or output during a genuinely hard stretch. The retreat has a purpose. It isn't the same thing as quitting.

Winter Ends, and Changes You

The book is careful not to romanticize difficult periods as purely good for you, but it does insist that a winter handled honestly, rather than denied or rushed, tends to leave something useful behind: a clearer sense of what actually matters, a recalibrated pace, sometimes a genuinely different set of priorities. The people who come out of a hard period worse off are often the ones who spent the whole time pretending it wasn't happening, rather than the ones who let themselves actually go through it.

Why It Matters for Leaders

The leaders this book challenges most are the ones who pride themselves on never being down, never missing a beat, always on. That reputation is often real discipline, but it's sometimes just a longer runway before a bigger crash, because nobody can actually hold a constant summer-level pace forever, and pretending otherwise just moves the bill to later.

The practical use of this idea is permission, pointed in two directions. First, at yourself: if you're genuinely in a hard stretch, naming it plainly to your own manager and deliberately narrowing your scope for a while isn't a performance failure, it's the move that gets you through intact instead of burning out in public two months later. Second, at your team: when someone's output or visibility drops during an obviously hard period, the first question shouldn't be "are they still committed," it should be "is this a reasonable retreat, and what would help it end well."

That second question matters because retreat and quitting look similar from the outside and are not the same thing. A hibernating animal isn't failing to survive winter, it's surviving it. Reading a team member's pulled-back state as a performance problem, rather than a temporary and sometimes necessary adjustment, can turn a short, well-managed hard season into a much longer one, or push someone out the door who would have come back stronger with a little room.

Picture a director, Noor, whose best engineer goes quiet for a few weeks after a family loss, missing some meetings and visibly working at half capacity. The instinct to escalate it as a performance issue would be the wrong read. The better move is a direct, honest conversation: what does she need to keep running, what can genuinely wait, and what's a real signal that she's ready to pick back up to full scope. Handled that way, the engineer comes back whole instead of resentful, and Noor keeps someone worth keeping.

Putting It Together

May's argument chains simply: winters are a normal, recurring season rather than a personal malfunction, they're best handled by adapting your pace and expectations rather than fighting to maintain a summer-level output, retreat during one is a strategy and not a failure, and a winter faced honestly tends to end with something genuinely useful intact. For a manager, the practical implication is as much about how you treat your own hard seasons as how you respond when someone on your team is visibly in one.

Wintering mind-map: Winter Is Normal Not Failure, the Cost of Performing Fine, Doing Winter Well Not Fighting It, Retreat Is a Strategy, and Winter Ends and Changes You, branching from the book's cover

Your chat with Kyoshi about the book Wintering

What to do next

Reinforce your understanding of Wintering

Books related to Wintering

Burnout

Burnout

The Nagoski sisters' sharp distinction between a stressor and the stress itself, and why removing the stressor from your life doesn't automatically get the stress out of your body. A rethink for any manager who treats "just manage your workload better" as the fix.

Crucial Conversations

Crucial Conversations

A manager's guide to the book about the story you make up before you open your mouth. It's not really a book about talking, but about the half-second before you talk that decides whether the conversation goes well or badly.

Four Thousand Weeks

Four Thousand Weeks

Oliver Burkeman's blunt reminder that the average human life is about four thousand weeks long, and that every productivity system built to escape that limit is making the anxiety worse, not better.

Grit

Grit

Angela Duckworth's research-backed case that sustained passion and perseverance beat raw talent, a useful gut-check for any manager who keeps betting on the "naturally gifted" hire over the stubborn one.

Hidden Potential

Hidden Potential

Adam Grant's argument that where you start matters far less than how far you're willing to grow, and that the character skills enabling that growth are learnable, not innate, no matter how your scorecard looks on day one.

Mindset

Mindset

Carol Dweck's research on why some people treat ability as fixed and others treat it as something built, and why the belief you hold about yourself shapes how your whole team learns, fails, and improves, often without anyone noticing it happening.

Rest

Rest

Alex Soojung-Kim Pang's argument that rest isn't the opposite of great work. It's part of how great work gets made. A useful corrective for any manager who treats recovery as what's left over after hustle.

Slow Productivity

Slow Productivity

Cal Newport's challenge to "busy equals productive": a case that most knowledge work rewards visible activity over actual output, and a different model built on doing less, at a sustainable pace, to a genuinely higher standard.

Stillness Is the Key

Stillness Is the Key

Ryan Holiday's case that the people who handle pressure, power, and chaos best aren't the busiest or the most driven, they're the ones who've built real stillness into their mind, body, and sense of purpose, usually against the current of everything around them.

Stolen Focus

Stolen Focus

Johann Hari's argument that your attention problem probably isn't a personal willpower failure, it's a predictable outcome of systems deliberately engineered to fragment it. Uncomfortable reading for any manager who's told a struggling employee to "just focus better."

The 5AM Club

The 5AM Club

Robin Sharma's parable-driven case for owning the first hour of your day before the world gets a vote. Less about waking up early for its own sake, and more about who's actually running your mornings.

The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People

The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People

Stephen Covey's classic, read through a modern-manager lens. Many of the ideas taught today as "new" leadership frameworks were already captured here decades ago.

The Daily Stoic

The Daily Stoic

A year of short, daily meditations drawn from Marcus Aurelius, Seneca, and Epictetus, organized into one practical claim: the ancient Stoics weren't writing philosophy for philosophers. They were writing a manual for getting through hard days without losing yourself.

The Obstacle Is the Way

The Obstacle Is the Way

Ryan Holiday's modern take on Stoic philosophy, built around a single claim: the obstacle in front of you isn't blocking the path, it is the path. A sharp antidote to managers who treat setbacks as proof the plan was wrong.

Triggers

Triggers

Executive coach Marshall Goldsmith's case that you don't fail to become the leader you intend to be because of weak character. You fail because your environment is triggering the wrong behavior all day without much notice, and nobody built a structure to catch it.

When the Body Says No

When the Body Says No

Gabor Maté's case, drawn from decades of clinical practice, that chronically suppressing your own needs and emotions to keep the peace has a real physical cost. A hard look at the leader who's never once said no and wears it as a point of pride.

Skills related to Wintering

Frameworks related to Wintering